Employee benefit programs can fall out of sync quickly. Tax rules evolve, agencies issue new guidance, and workforce needs shift. If your organization sponsors a cafeteria plan (Internal Revenue Code Section 125), scheduling periodic “checkups” helps protect the plan’s tax advantages and ensures the benefit menu still delivers real value to employees.
What a cafeteria plan is and why it matters
A cafeteria plan is a formal benefits arrangement that satisfies IRC Section 125 requirements. Its core purpose is to let eligible employees choose between:
- Taxable cash compensation, or
- A selection of tax-free (or tax-advantaged) benefits.
Common options can include:
- Group-term life insurance (up to $50,000)
- Accident and health coverage
- Health Flexible Spending Accounts (health FSAs)
- Dependent care assistance programs
- Adoption assistance
Most plans are funded through employee salary reductions, though employers may also contribute via nonelective contributions. The big win: employees generally reduce taxable income by paying for eligible benefits with pretax dollars, and employers may reduce payroll taxes tied to those elections.
Align plan design with strategy and your workforce
One of the strongest advantages of cafeteria plans is their flexibility. That’s also why it’s smart to periodically step back with leadership and professional advisors to ask whether your current design still supports your organization’s goals and your team’s demographics.
For example, some employers operate premium-only plans (POPs) that allow employees to pay their share of accident and health premiums with pretax earnings. Others allow pretax contributions to accounts such as:
- FSAs, which let participants set aside funds for qualifying medical and/or dependent care expenses
- HSAs, which can be used to pay or reimburse qualified medical expenses (when paired with a qualifying high-deductible health plan and other IRS eligibility rules)
Note: To contribute to an HSA, an employee generally must be covered by a qualifying high-deductible health plan and meet additional IRS requirements.
Compliance is where many plans stumble
Although cafeteria plans are governed primarily by Section 125, many benefits offered through the plan (health coverage and health FSAs) may also trigger ERISA reporting, disclosure, and fiduciary obligations.
Below are four high-impact compliance practices to build into your ongoing plan maintenance.
1) Keep plan documents current and easy to access
Section 125 requires a written cafeteria plan document. In addition, ERISA-covered benefits typically require a Summary Plan Description (SPD) and other disclosures. New participants should receive a current SPD when first eligible, and existing participants should receive updates when material changes occur.
Checkup action items
- Confirm the plan document reflects the current benefit menu, eligibility rules, and election/change procedures.
- Verify distribution practices for SPDs and required notices.
- Maintain a central repository (HRIS, intranet, or benefits portal) so participants can readily access current materials.
2) Prevent ineligible participation
A key rule: only common-law employees can participate in a cafeteria plan on a pretax basis. Certain individuals, such as partners in partnerships and more-than-2% S corporation shareholders,are generally treated as self-employed for these purposes and are not eligible for pretax participation. Allowing ineligible participants can jeopardize the plan’s qualified status.
Checkup action items
- Review eligibility definitions and how HR/Payroll systems apply them.
- Audit enrollment lists against ownership/partner status.
- Train administrators to spot edge cases (e.g., ownership changes during the year).
3) Perform nondiscrimination testing on schedule
Section 125 requires cafeteria plans to satisfy nondiscrimination rules, meaning the plan cannot unfairly favor highly compensated or key employees in eligibility, contributions, or benefits. Testing should be done at least annually, and more often when plan participation or demographics change in ways that create risk.
Some small employers may be eligible for simplified testing by adopting a “simple cafeteria plan” (generally available to businesses with fewer than 100 employees) that provides minimum benefit levels to eligible participants who are not highly compensated or key employees.
Checkup action items
- Calendar annual tests and assign accountability.
- Re-test after major workforce events (acquisitions, layoffs, benefit redesigns).
- Keep workpapers in case of audit or inquiry.
4) Stay current on administrative requirements
Beyond testing, cafeteria plans bring practical administrative responsibilities: recordkeeping, participant notices, and reporting. Depending on how underlying benefits are structured, some plan assets can also become subject to ERISA trust requirements. Keeping up with these operational details and any new or updated federal guidance is critical.
Checkup action items
- Confirm documentation and retention practices for elections, changes, and substantiation.
- Review vendor responsibilities (TPA, payroll, benefits broker) and confirm there are no gaps.
- Evaluate whether any trust requirements apply based on your benefit structure.
Practical “checkup” checklist (quick scan)
Use this as a simple starting point for your next review:
- Plan design fit: Do your offerings match employee needs and your talent strategy?
- Documents: Are the plan document and (if applicable) SPD updated and distributed correctly?
- Eligibility controls: Are only eligible common-law employees participating pretax?
- Nondiscrimination testing: Is testing performed on time, with records retained?
- Operations: Are enrollment, changes, substantiation, notices, reporting, and recordkeeping consistently handled?
- Vendor coordination: Are responsibilities clearly defined and monitored?
Bottom line
A cafeteria plan can be a powerful tool for delivering tax-efficient benefits, yet it isn’t a “set it and forget it” program. Routine reviews help preserve compliance, avoid unpleasant surprises, and keep benefits meaningful for employees. If you’d like help evaluating your plan design, documentation, testing approach, and administrative processes, we can assist with a thorough cafeteria plan review.
©2026
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1) What is a Section 125 cafeteria plan?
A Section 125 cafeteria plan is a formal employee benefits arrangement that allows eligible employees to choose between taxable cash compensation and a menu of tax-free or tax-advantaged benefits, such as certain health coverage and FSAs.
2) Who can participate in a cafeteria plan on a pretax basis?
Generally, only common-law employees can participate pretax. Individuals treated as self-employed for this purpose, such as partners and more-than-2% S corporation shareholders, are typically ineligible for pretax cafeteria plan participation.
3) How often should nondiscrimination testing be done?
Section 125 nondiscrimination testing should be performed at least annually, and it may be wise to test more frequently after significant changes in workforce demographics or benefits design that could increase compliance risk.
4) Do cafeteria plans have ERISA requirements?
Cafeteria plans themselves are governed by Section 125, but many underlying benefits offered through them (health coverage and health FSAs) may be subject to ERISA reporting, disclosure, and fiduciary requirements (including SPDs and other notices).